Skip to content

Got a non-renewal letter? Your next 75 days

Got a non-renewal letter from your home insurance company? You have time, but not much to waste. In California, your insurer has to give you at least 75 days' written notice before your policy ends, and the letter has to say why. Use those 75 days to find out the reason, shop admitted carriers first, and keep the FAIR Plan as a fallback, not a first move.

Here's how to use that time well.

What does a non-renewal actually mean?

A non-renewal means your current insurer won't offer you a new policy when this one expires. Your coverage stays in force until the expiration date. You're not uninsured today, and you don't need to panic-buy the first policy you're offered.

It's also different from a cancellation. A cancellation ends a policy mid-term, and in California that can only happen for limited reasons like non-payment or fraud. A non-renewal just means the insurer is choosing not to continue.

Why are so many California homes getting non-renewed?

Most non-renewals right now have little to do with the homeowner. Carriers have been pulling back across California because of wildfire risk, rising rebuild costs and reinsurance prices. Some have stopped writing new policies in whole ZIP codes.

But some non-renewals are about the house itself, and those you may be able to fix:

  • An older roof, or one the insurer saw in an aerial photo
  • Brush or trees too close to the home
  • Outdated electrical, plumbing or water heater
  • A recent claim, or several smaller ones

Read the reason on your notice. California requires the insurer to state it. If it's something you can fix, a repair and photos can sometimes change the outcome.

Your 75-day plan

Days 1–7: Read the letter and gather your documents

  • Find the expiration date and the reason.
  • Pull your current declarations page (the summary of your coverage and limits).
  • Note anything you've updated recently: roof, electrical, plumbing, smoke detectors, fire-resistant vents.

Days 7–30: Fix what you can and start shopping

  • If the reason is fixable, call your agent or insurer and ask what they'd need to see.
  • Start shopping now, not in week ten. Underwriting takes time, and some carriers order an inspection before they'll bind.
  • Work with an independent agent who can check several admitted carriers at once. An admitted carrier is licensed and rate-regulated by the state, and its claims are protected by the California Insurance Guarantee Association if the insurer fails.

Days 30–60: Compare real options

Compare more than the price:

What to compareWhy it matters
Dwelling limitShould match today's cost to rebuild, not your home's market value
Replacement cost vs. actual cash valueActual cash value subtracts depreciation from claim payments
DeductibleSome policies use a separate, higher wildfire deductible
Loss of usePays for rent and living costs if you can't stay home during repairs
LiabilityProtects you if someone is hurt on your property

Days 60–75: Bind before the gap

Never let the policy lapse. If you have a mortgage, your lender requires continuous coverage and can buy expensive force-placed insurance for you if it lapses. Bind your new policy so it starts the day the old one ends.

When the FAIR Plan makes sense

The California FAIR Plan is the state's insurer of last resort. It mainly covers fire, lightning, smoke and internal explosion. It does not include liability, theft or water damage the way a homeowners policy does.

If the FAIR Plan is the only option, most homeowners pair it with a difference in conditions (DIC) policy from a separate carrier. The DIC policy fills in what the FAIR Plan leaves out. Together they come close to a standard homeowners policy, with two bills instead of one.

Keep shopping after you land on the FAIR Plan. Carriers re-enter markets, and an agent can check again at each renewal.

How it often plays out

Say a homeowner gets a non-renewal in mid-August for a policy that expires November 1, and the reason is "wildfire risk score."

  • Week one: they send their agent the declarations page and mention the roof was replaced in 2021.
  • Week three: two admitted carriers decline, and a third asks for photos of the roof and defensible space.
  • Week six: the third carrier approves the home, with a dwelling limit updated to current rebuild costs.

Not every search ends with an admitted carrier. But starting early is what gives you the most choices.

Frequently asked questions

How much notice does my insurer have to give before non-renewing my home policy in California? California law requires at least 75 days' written notice before the policy expires, and the notice has to give the reason.

Can I appeal a homeowners non-renewal? There's no formal appeal. But you can ask the insurer to reconsider if the reason is fixable. If you think the notice broke the rules, you can file a complaint with the California Department of Insurance.

Is the California FAIR Plan my only option after a non-renewal? No. Many non-renewed homes can still be placed with another admitted carrier. The FAIR Plan is the fallback, usually paired with a DIC policy.

Does a non-renewal hurt my chances with other insurers? Insurers will ask, and you need to answer honestly. A non-renewal for wildfire risk or a carrier leaving an area is common right now and usually isn't treated like a claims history.

Let's take a look at your home

We've helped California homeowners through non-renewals since 1991, across 20 carriers, including specialty markets for hard-to-place homes. Send us your notice and declarations page, and we'll tell you honestly what your options are. See your options or call (714) 990-1382.

This article is general information, not legal advice. Coverage depends on your policy and carrier.

Questions about your own policy?

CallGet a quote